The three routes
| Route | Initiated by | Used for | Not used for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Withdrawal | Customer through cashier | Available account balance | Disputing a card transaction |
| Merchant refund | Operator/merchant | Reversing or correcting a payment | Guaranteed recovery after gambling losses |
| Chargeback | Cardholder through issuer | Specific card-scheme dispute grounds | Changing your mind or automatically undoing authorised play |
Chargeback is not an automatic right
The Banking Ombudsman explains that Visa or Mastercard cardholders can ask a bank to attempt a chargeback, but grounds and time limits come from card rules. Attempts can fail. Common grounds include an unauthorised transaction, duplicate/wrong amount, or paid-for service not provided. A bank generally does not decide ordinary disputes about service quality.
The Ombudsman notes that a chargeback may be possible in limited circumstances if an online company refuses to allow withdrawal of an available balance. That is not a guarantee and should not be presented as one.
Evidence for a payment dispute
Keep:
- bank statement entry and merchant descriptor;
- card transaction date, amount and currency;
- proof of whether you authorised it;
- duplicate or wrong-amount evidence;
- operator account ledger and withdrawal request;
- written attempts to resolve the issue;
- final operator response;
- date you contacted the bank.
Act promptly because card contracts set deadlines. Do not invent an “unauthorised” claim for a payment you approved; the merchant can provide authentication and account records.
Refund and foreign exchange
A foreign-currency refund can post at a different exchange rate from the original debit. Some issuer terms state that the original conversion charge is not refunded. Compare the original source amount, original NZD debit, refund currency and final NZD credit.
Bank transfer recovery is different
A bank transfer does not use card-scheme chargeback rules. If it was a mistaken or fraudulent payment, contact the bank immediately. Recovery may depend on the receiving account and timing. Consumer Protection says recovery from bank transfers is generally less likely than a card chargeback; cryptocurrency or gift-card recovery is very unlikely.
A safe escalation order
- Identify whether the issue is an account withdrawal, merchant refund or disputed payment.
- Use the operator’s formal complaint route for an account/withdrawal issue.
- Contact the bank promptly for an unauthorised, duplicate, wrong-amount or otherwise eligible card dispute.
- Give facts and documents; ask which chargeback reason and deadline apply.
- If the bank mishandles the process, use its complaint process and then the Banking Ombudsman where eligible.
Sources
- Banking Ombudsman: chargebacks, updated December 2024.
- Consumer Protection: report a scam, checked 14 November 2026.
- Consumer Protection: credit cards, checked 14 November 2026.
- Banking Ombudsman: mistaken payments, updated December 2024.


